Tech Notes: Clean Air Lines
You’ve heard the old oil-change adage: pay a little now for a filter or pay a lot later for a new engine. Well the same can be said when it comes to the air supply on a coordinate measuring machine (CMM).
You can check and replace your compressor air line filters for less than $20, or you can wait until the air lines become contaminated, damaging the CMM and costing about a week of downtime and $8,000 for repairs.
We’ve seen it happen too many times. Oil and/or water gets into the air lines contaminating the air bearings, and causing amplifiers to blowout. At that point, the only thing you can do is replace everything.
But this is all too easy to avoid. It starts with the compressor filters and air line filters on your CMM. There are normally two filters — the liquid separator filter and the particle filter — that should be inspected once a week and replaced as needed.
Depending on the CMM and the compressor, there may be two filters on the CMM and two on the compressor. Each filter needs to be taken out and the element visibly inspected. It takes about 10 minutes.
The cubic-feet-per-minute output of your compressor will dictate which filters to use and how many. Each filter element costs under $20 and can be ordered from any good industrial equipment distributor.
We also recommend a refrigerant dryer be attached to the compressor to take the moisture out of the air before it is sent through the filters. This will prolong the life of the filters and help avoid contamination.
Of course, if you’ve got the money, the cleanest “air” to use is nitrogen. It’s what NASCAR racers use with their pneumatic tools. However, it is very expensive and we know of only one company using it, and that’s because they have other uses for the nitrogen. Of course you still need a liquid separator filter and you’ve got to check it once a week.
So, pay for the filters now, or pay for the replacement of air bearings, lines and who knows what else later. It’s up to you.
Thom Hoey
EMD Systems Engineer
Electronic Measuring Devices, Inc. (EMD) is a reputable company manufacturing scanning heads and specialty CMMs. The newsletter is from Fall of 1998.
Figure 1
In contrast, a mechanical bearing CMM, with direct contact between bearings and ways, offers structural rigidity even when on the fly. This rigid dynamic machine geometry is ideal for manual CMM inspection techniques. At Helmel, we teach the use of the probe bar. It seems a more natural way to use the machine and certainly results in faster inspection. The machines operate swiftly and accurately and gives the operator a confident, solid feel.
Air bearing machines tend to drift if not leveled perfectly. A side benefit of mechanical bearings related to reliability has to do with the very minimal amount of inherent friction they provide. A properly leveled machine will not drift when the probe bar is released, and therefore will not accidentally take unwanted points. Watch any operator of a manual air bearing machine; to overcome this annoyance the most frequently used features are the X and Y locks.
We would certainly agree that the DCC environment is better suited to air bearing construction than manual use is. Since the driving force is applied closer to the ways the condition as per figure (1) is greatly diminished in normal applications. However, DCC machines are becoming faster and faster. An air-bearing machine will reach speed limitations long before a mechanical bearing machine. Rapid directional changes and acceleration rates will cause air bearings to bottom out, score and damage themselves. They are not durable enough for high-speed applications. It is interesting to note that, where high speed or harsh environments are anticipated, mechanical bearings are used. The Sheffield Discovery II Series is an example of this.
We would argue that mechanical bearing construction is the best all around approach, whether manual or DCC, but especially when a machine may be used in both modes.
